Low protein intake is associated with a major reduction in IGF-1, cancer, and overall mortality in the 65 and younger but not older population

Summary

This Cell Metabolism paper combined a large NHANES-based human cohort (2,253 adults followed over 18 years) with mouse experiments to ask whether high protein intake — especially animal protein — drives cancer and mortality risk via IGF-1 and growth-hormone signalling. The headline finding is age-dependent. In adults aged 50–65, those reporting high protein intake (≥20 percent of calories from protein) had a 75 percent higher overall mortality and a fourfold higher cancer death risk over the next 18 years compared to low-protein eaters (under 10 percent of calories). The effect was largely abolished when the protein came from plant sources rather than animal sources. After age 65, the relationship reversed: high protein became protective for cancer and overall mortality — though high protein at any age was associated with a fivefold increase in diabetes mortality. Mouse experiments supported the mechanism: high-protein diets accelerated tumour growth and elevated IGF-1, while protein restriction did the opposite. The interpretation is that protein's relationship with longevity is not monotonic; it depends on age, on the protein source, and on what's being optimized for.